On Day 50 of The Doctor Who Mind Robber’s Countdown to Doctor Who’s 50th Anniversary we published our list of the Ten Most Wanted Missing Episodes. Not all episodes are as highly sought after as others and unfortunately there are a limited number that many fans have little or no desire to see returned. Our list of those sad and sorry stories that pine for some respect is provided in broadcast order only.
1. Galaxy 4 – Season 3
The first broadcast of our least wanted missing stories is the Season 3 opener, Galaxy 4. Until November 2011 none of the story’s four episodes were held in the BBC Archives. Upon episode three’s discovery, a reconstruction of the serial was produced and included as an extra in The Aztecs Special Edition. The recovered episode was included in the reconstruction.
Although the resident monsters of the serial, the Rill and the Chumblies, are generally well regarded the story is nonetheless frequently discounted by fans. In The Discontinuity Guide (1995) Paul Cornell, Martin Day and Keith Topping’s “Bottom Line” was that “Galaxy 4 presents an interesting if flawed twist on the traditional bug-eyed monster tale”.
Arguably it is most probably the presence of the chief villains, the Drahvins, which is the cause of most distain for Galaxy 4. Personally I found the concept of a female dominated, anti-male race of aliens absolutely enthralling. It’s for that reason that I rated the serial so highly in my own marathon watch. Below is an example of one of the recent anti-Galaxy 4 tweets. The diversity of Doctor Who fandom is one of its greatest strengths.
2. The Celestial Toymaker – Season 3
Prior to the recovery and release of episode four The Celestial Toymaker was held in reasonably high regard. In Peter Haining’s 1983 coffee table book, Doctor Who A Celebration, Jeremy Bentham waxed lyrical about it.
The success of this story lies in the way if visualises a child’s nightmare – the secret world of toys from the nursery coming to life, harmless games that insidiously graduate into something far more sinister, smiling, happy faces concealing deadly menace. In short it was a perfect fairy-tale of the kind told by the brothers Grimm – a multi-level fantasy appealing to young and old alike, but strangely being more disturbing to adults than to children.
The widespread availability of episode 4, firstly on the 1991 VHS release and then on 2004’s DVD, Lost in Time, quickly lead to the story’s reputation diminishing. In Mark Campell’s widely read basic guide, Doctor Who The Complete Series Guide, he gives the serial only 4 out of 10. His verdict is as follows:
A weird, and at times plodding, excursion into pure fantasy (some might say whimsy). Not as interesting as its reputation might suggest.
My own marathon review of The Celestial Toymaker was rather more positive. In introducing the story I stated:
I found the story engaging and fascinating. The concept of a world of make believe in which the characters are compelled to participate in childish games in order to retrieve the TARDIS is both sinister and surreal. That I’m a great fan of the Second Doctor’s The Mind Robber probably evidences my idiosyncratic tendencies. Both serials have a similar edge about them.
3. The Underwater Menace – Season 4
Another poor and lowly regarded story is The Underwater Menace. Episode 3 is included on Lost in Time, and although episode 2 was recovered in November 2011 it has yet to be released on DVD. You have to wonder what that omission says about both the popularity and the quality of the serial. The Discontinuity Guide displayed its distain for the serial in its bottom line summary:
‘I could feed you to my pet octopus – yes? … I, too, have a sense of humour!’ At least Joe Orton got a kick out of watching Frazer Hines in episode four of this story.
To find out more about the Joe Orton/Doctor Who connection I suggest you read this blog post.
In my marathon review of The Underwater Menace I successfully found some merit in the story and ended my article by stating, “ The Underwater Menace is a fun romp and nowhere near as bad as its reputation. Watch it with an eye for the ridiculous and you won’t be disappointed”.
4. The Wheel in Space – Season 5
As the lovely Wendy Padbury’s debut story, one would have thought that The Wheel in Space would be a fine contender in the list of the most sought after missing episodes. Moreover, the story features the Cybermen and is the last of a long and continuous run of missing Series 5 stories. That’s enough to make anyone celebrate. Not so for the authors of The Discontinuity Guide who again panned the story:
Dull, lifeless and so derivative of other base-under-siege stories that it isn’t really a story in its own right. Despite the detailed Wheel setting, the galloping lack of scientific credibility is annoying, and the Cybermen are so bland and ordinary that they could have been any other monster. Generic speed-written tosh.
As a great fan of the companion Zoe I nonetheless enjoyed The Wheel in Space. There can never be too much Zoe.
5. The Space Pirates – Season 6
Coming in at 195 in the 2009 Doctor Who Magazine Mighty 200, The Space Pirates has the unfortunate reputation as the least popular Patrick Troughton era Doctor Who serial. It is also the last story that is missing from the BBC Archives. Being totally bereft of any telesnaps, and having a muddy and almost inaudible fan saved soundtrack, Loose Cannon’s reconstruction of The Space Pirates does not make for very engaging viewing. So bad was it that I had great difficulty reviewing the story. I was, however, impressed by Madelaine Issigri’s fabulous metal hair and Zoe’s hotpants! The only episode held in the BBC Archives has been released on the Lost in Time DVD.
©Vivien Fleming, 2013.
The last several days, as the rumors of recovered episodes have swirled and reached fever pitch, I have actually found myself wishing “If it’s true, then please don’t let it be The Space Pirates!”
I was actually relatively happy at the discovery of one of Galaxy Four’s missing episodes. For many years, I had really been curious about what the mysterious Rills looked like. Seeing various still photographs from the recovered episode, I think they actually look quite cool & distinctive. Plus the Chumblies are adorable.
As for The Celestial Toymaker, if the still-missing episodes of it ever did get recovered, I really have to wonder what the heck the BBC would do about the fact that one of the characters says the N-word!
Were said episode returned, I doubt they’d have any alternative but to sound-engineer that word out of existence, perhaps replacing it with ‘Tiger’.
Pingback: Missing Episodes Delay 50th Anniversary Countdown | The Doctor Who Mind Robber
While it wouldn’t top my list of episodes to recover, I’m glad to see that I’m not the only one who has some affection for “The Celestial Toymaker.” I think the concept of the Toymaker is a fascinating one, and the story feels to me like it has a bit of an Alice in Wonderland influence.
I, too, had a first reaction of ‘What’s the Celestial Toymaker doing on this list?’ Not in my top 5, maybe… but definitely not in my bottom 5, either. I find the character, and his history with the Doctor, fascinating.
Pingback: Review: Who’s 50: The 50 Doctor Who Stories to Watch Before You Die | Book Bliss
Before “The Enemy Of The World” was returned, it was panned as well because unlike the rest of Season Five, it was a spy-thriller, not the typical base under siege story that was the Second Doctor’s strong suit. They also were going off of only Episode 3 and the audio. Who knows? I’ll take any lost episodes, even these. Now, after it’s recovery, it’s praised as one of Troughton’s best stories.
Quite honestly, the episodes we should wanted least recovered are those already with animated versions produced. (except the Tenth Planet episode 4, of course). I mean, those episodes are already watched in some format, whereas missing episodes without animated reconstructions aren’t watchable. New material or duplicates of old material?